
Being Heumann is writer-director Sian Heder’s follow-up to the Oscar-winning Coda. A biopic about activist Judith Heumann, one of the most prominent figures in disability rights in America from the 1970s until her death in 2023, Being Heumann focuses on one of Heumann’s major political stands against government indifference.
Being Heumann takes us to 1977 when Heumann leads a sit-in occupation of the San Francisco Health, Education and Welfare offices. The goal is to force the federal government to sign Section 504 of the 1973 Rehabilitation Act into law and enable people with disabilities to have safe and appropriate access to public spaces. She is joined by a loyal alliance of marginalised groups, including gay action parties and the Black Panthers.
Played by Ruth Madeley (whose English accent is nowhere to be heard), Judith Heumann is stubborn, brusque and oftentimes unfriendly – a woman who knows that there’s no space for asking nicely. Madeley also brings a sympathetic edge to Heumann. Her passion is infectious and you share in both her frustrations and exaltations.
Heumann’s biggest obstacle comes in the shape of Secretary for Health, Joseph Califano, played by Mark Ruffalo who, although perfectly adequate in his performance, may be going through the motions somewhat in this role.

Let’s get the positives out there. Being Heumann is an entertaining and eye-opening account of an injustice that is still being fought to this day. The movie has a strong message that it firmly believes in, and the performances given are impressive. Madeley deserves the praise she has been getting, giving a forthright and sympathetic performance. An extra shoutout goes to Dylan O’Brien who plays TV reporter Evan White, a smaller role that he absolutely shines in.
But the big problem is its presentation.
Being Heumann would have benefited so much from being a mini-series, akin to 2020’s Mrs America. We spend a large chunk of the movie with the protestors at their month-long sit-in. Although a number of individuals are given backstories (some, if not all, based on or inspired by their real-life counterparts), there simply isn’t enough time to spend significant time with them all. Which is a shame and a missed opportunity. There isn’t enough time to breathe, ruminate and come to terms with the setbacks the group endures.
Another lesser quibble is that the movie looks far too clean. It’s a period piece but aside from a few corded telephones and bell-bottomed trousers it is easy to forget that this all takes place in the 70s. Arguably, Heder was more interested in the message of the story than developing strong narrative art but the lack of interesting direction or cinematography results in a rather paint-by-numbers approach.
Nonetheless, Being Heumann tells an interesting and genuinely moving story that humanises and educates. If only the movie’s direction took a leaf out of its subjects’ book and dared to challenge the status quo.
Being Heumann is in cinemas from 6 November and available on Apple TV from 13 November.
